Friday, October 21, 2005
Peer Review
Yesterday, Red State Rabble published the transcript of Michael Behe's testimony in the Dover intelligent design trial concerning the peer review of his book Darwin's Black Box. Now, one of the "reviewers," Dr. Michael Atchison, head of biochemistry in the department of animal biology at the University of Pennsylvania, has told the story of his participation in the "review."
It's making quite a splash around the web. You can read Ed Brayton's comments on Panda's Thumb, John Lynch's comments at Stranger Fruit, or Atchison's own comments on Mustard Seed.
Was the peer review less than vigorous. You be the judge.
It's making quite a splash around the web. You can read Ed Brayton's comments on Panda's Thumb, John Lynch's comments at Stranger Fruit, or Atchison's own comments on Mustard Seed.
Was the peer review less than vigorous. You be the judge.
